Christine Stückelberger Clinic: Getting Out of the Comfort Zone in Favour of the Horses

Sat, 04/09/2022 - 10:02
Training Your Horse
Christine Stückelberger with Maya Thumm's Württemberger mare Denaria (by Denario x Dr.Jackson) at the clinic in Heimsheim on 27 March 2022 :: Photo © Silke Rottermann

-- Text and Photos © Silke Rottermann for Eurodressage

It is a good question why it took me a so long time to visit a clinic of Christine Stückelberger, THE dressage rider of the 1970s? I have known Christine personally for almost 25 years and it is thanks to the generosity and patience of her lifelong trainer Georg Wahl (1920-2013) that nowadays I am able to tell apart a well trained horse from a poorly one. 

Christine’s teaching is, in a way, resembling that of her late trainer: She gets the riders out of their comfort zone in favour of their horses.

I finally took the opportunity to follow Christine’s teachings again on 27 March 2022. On that glorious sunny Sunday the Baroque Riding Center in Heimsheim, near Stuttgart, hosted the 2nd day of Christine’s first clinic there of 2022.

First seat, then legs, only then the reins

Those who first meet Christine Stückelberger would never expect this petite woman sitting in the corner of the beautiful indoor arena to have such  resilient strength almost 75 years of age. All her life Christine’s overwhelming love for horses has been the fuel that drives her. Her ambition is to make her students better riders, so they can do their horses as much justice as possible.

The strictness and consequence with which she challenged the riders in the clinic might have been a bit surprising for those who never met her before, but it is also exactly what her long-time students appreciate so much. And who thinks that training with an Olympic and World champion means finally riding a piaffe when the horse is still heavy on the hand or not sensitive to the leg, were proven deadly wrong.

Maya Thumm and Denaria were the youngest participants
, with the rider being 16 and the horse 7.
It was all about the correct basics for horse and rider alike. The horse’s basis can never be right if the rider is unable to communicate on a certain level. So no matter if  it were a pleasure rider or professional, Christine’s primary focus is first on seat and position and the aids.

"Back-to-front" riding is the main goal and this is only possible if the rider learns to ride from the seat, to initiate transitions without the reins, or to induce collection with the core. Not surprisingly  many riders struggled with that classical concept on which many trainers agree but so few insist on - at least in the persistent way Stückelberger does.

"Do not push! Let your horse do it itself"

First to go in the clinic on that Sunday morning was a horse girl's typical dream: a shiny black horse with long legs, and super refined head.

Daniela Wais on B' Happy who stretches properly at the
end of the lesson
The Westfalian mare B' Happy-Go-Lucky (by Bretton Woods x Rascalino) truly reflected the type of a modern dressage horse, but she is also what Stückelberger calls a „Ferrari“: very sensitive, but also strong willed and with quick reactions. Daniela Wais is her rider; she is an advanced riding instructor with a pedigree as good as her horse. Dorothee Schneider, Siegfried Peilicke, Holga Finken, Martin Plewa were the trainers who stamped her so far.
For the onlooker she sat and rode very nicely and refined, but Stückelberger sensed that the aids were still not on the level of refinement which the black mare was most comfortable with.

"You have to breathe and feel with your calf, your leg needs to be relaxed," she told the rider. Soon the mare trotted with a relaxation and a lovely rhythm that was a universe away from the tense disconnected trots with stiff backs we have to suffer so often on the international level. "The relaxed and content horse is our goal," Christine stressed and true to her word she got a little cross when tension creeped in the moment the mare should execute a transition into canter. "No counter pressure if your mare resists, on the contrary: Open your legs and put your hand forward," Christine advised. 

What sounded logical is less easy to immediately put into practice like a reflex. The 8-time Olympian was aware of it. The horse’s natural movements without tension is what she aims for and she showed the riders how to achieve it via riding with aids used at a minimum, but cleverly applied. "If horse and rider are in balance, the hind-legs are in the right place," said Stückelberger.

A loose noseband and a loose flash strap are the precondition
for achieving a contact which allows refined riding
Resistance is always corrected in a forward wat, but not by pushing the horse in a faster trot, but by ceasing with the aids and remaining calm.
The stunning black beauty got back into the harmony she showed at the beginning, snorting contently and with a tail carried in a relaxed way. She also did not get faster when Wais lengthened the reins for her to stretch. Instead she followed the hand with a lot of faith while keeping her tempo and beautiful rhythm.

It was a lesson which only focused on the horse feeling well and the rider becoming aware that despite her already very confirmed seat and position there is always room left for further improvement. 

"I totally appreciate Mrs. Stückelberger’s merciless strictness and honesty, her relentless corrections which pull myself completely out of the comfort zone," said the rider. "She is always friendly and the working atmosphere is very nice. Everything happens in favour of the horses and should be even more refined. This matches my sensitive mare very well as she is somebody who would never accept a 'you must'," Wais commented on her lesson in which there was no piaffe and passage, no pirouettes. 

Christine highlighted, "the movement went through the whole body of the horse and this is the true beauty of classical dressage."

"The horse can also do something by and carry herself"

Jana Willmann and Tosca in the warm-up frame
Jana Willmann and her 16-year-old Bavarian warmblood mare Tosca travelled all the way from Munich together with a stable mate and her former jumping horse, and this not for the first time. To her Stückelberger’s clinics are worth every kilometer and the onlooker could easily recognize that horse and rider are familiar with the teachings of the passionate Swiss.

Minimize the aids and allow the horse to work as much on its own as possible" is the credo which ran like a red thread through all of Christine's lessons. It created very harmonious pictures which we unfortunagely see too rarely in dressage sport.

"If you want to ride a half pass you have to initiate it from your seat. The inside hip indicates the lateral movement, but the horse also needs to have a certain will to go forward, it needs to react promptly to the leg aids or that kind of riding won’t work," she said. Only when Tosca was truly with her rider and as refined in the contact as Stückelberger wanted her to be, was Willmann allowed to attempt the trot half-passes. Only then "the horse can do something on her own and will carry herself."

Tosca with more elevation in the working phase.
Stückelberger’s words were put into practice and after some attempts Tosca showed fluent half-passes on both reins;  no pushing, no pressing, the horse showing remarkable self-carriage while being correctly flexed and bent.

In moments like these Christine Stückelberger can be enthusiastic and delighted like a little girl getting her desired Christmas present. Strictness and persistence then resolve in prompt and honest praise. A short "You did that really well" or "Did you feel that? Your horse can do it, but you have to allow her to work like that" are the clear reward for the riders, who lose sleep over the exciting opportunity of riding in front of the Olympic champion of 1976.

Praise is her key word when working with horses. This can also mean that if a horse has worked extremely well, Christine will sent him back to the stables even if there are 5 minutes left to a lesson. With horses you cannot really set the clock, so sometimes she was also working a bit longer with some horses than the foreseen 30 minutes unit.

"Impulsion resides in collection and not in chasing the horse forward"

The most interesting part of clinics like these lies in the often wide variety of horses and riders you see. It can range from professionals to pleasure riders, with the ambitious amateur in between and their likewise different four legged partners. On such occasion one can see whether a teaching method of a trainer - no matter how famous -  is working and can be generally applied or not.

Elke Thumm and her 12-year-old Lipizzan gelding Pluto
Pompas grew beyond themselves, the horse developing
unexpected impulsion within just one lesson.
As I have known Christine Stückelberger for a comparatively long time, I did not doubt she is part of that group of trainers who can deal with every kind of rider and horse because with her it is always first about correct basics. However, to this date it still stuns  me how much some horses change in just one single lesson because Christine’s advice is so sound and some riders are simply able to put them faster into practice than others.

One of these clever riders was Elke Thumm who brought her 12-year-old Lipizzan gelding Pluto Pompas for their first lessons with Stückelberger.
The small compact grey used to be a driving horse until a few years ago. He is described as "a horse who loves to work."  Stückelberger’s lifelong trainer Georg Wahl was chief rider at the Spanish Riding School in Vienna and, therefore, she is well acquainted with this breed and their peculiarities.

"I came to the clinic because I wanted to improve the throughness of my horse. Mrs. Stückelberger has a very straight way of teaching to which I needed to get used to on the first day, but today I really tried hard to put her advice immediately into practice," Thumm said.

Stückelberger giving explanations to Daniela Wais
Again Stückelberger centred the lesson by first focusing on the rider’s seat: "If you want the horse to react promptly, you need to open your knee and relax your lower leg. The calves do not apply pressure, they just support the rhythm of the horse," said Christine.  As soon as the rider did exactly this, the little Lipizzan truly became a different horse: one with a more natural will to go forward, now clearly using his back and his hind-legs and stepping into a soft contact. As a result he started to swing through his whole body.

It was a true pleasure to observe how this little horse’s expression and impulsion increased. "You are a natural," Stückelberger praised and then added something which I wisheshe would shout out loudly to those confusing speed for impulsion: "Because impulsion resides in collection and not in chasing the horse forward."

However, that new way of going created new challenges for the rider in sitting trot. "Avoid to compensate this new degree of impulsion by clamping with your knees and legs. Instead open your knees and stretch the leg from the hip down to the heels," was the advice. "The tilting of your pelvis will then act as a kind of shock absorber and allows you to sit.“

Good Equitation is Simply Beautiful and Likewise Challenging

Stückelberger encouraged all riders to find the feel good frame
of their horses, here a sympathetic Oldenburger gelding.
After witnessing several very different horse-rider-combinations in a seven-hour clinic, it felt nice to step out side of the cool indoor arena into the glorious sunshine. That particular Sunday felt like early summer in late March.

Even though the person who gave it her all throughout the day was certainly no stranger to me, I remembered how beautiful good equitation looks like, but also how challenging it is to achieve by the riders.

The peculiarity of Switzerland’s most successful dressage rider of all times is that she challenges the riders to make everything as easy and stress-free for their horses as possible. She works on the riders in that way and by doing so the horses improve as well. There was not one minute pressure or stress for the horses because as soon as the slightest tension creeped in, Stückelberger came to the fore, had the expertise and eye to detect the cause, and helped the riders to eliminate it without bothering their horses.

This approach is certainly one of the most demanding and difficult ways to teach proper riding, but definitely also one of the most profound and horse friendly ones on the planet!

Nuggets of Wisdom from Christine Stückelberger

"Your hand has to act in last place. Your legs initiate the bending, your erected core collection.“

"We are riding too much with our brains and too little with our feeling. Riding by intuition gets lost.“

"You have to explore what is the feel-good frame of your horse, instead of pressing it into the frame you want it to go in.“

"If you ride a horse with a long back downwards, you bring it on the forehand. Then you will have a hard time getting it up again.“

"You should not only ride, but you also need to read a book about equitation now and then.“

Silke Rottermann and Christine Stückelberger
"If you want to ride a soft transition from canter to trot, it is enough to pull at your toes and the canter aid automatically stops.“

"To give with the hand is the key to success."

"Your wrist needs to be as agile as if you want to play an instrument.“

"If you want to ride a transition to walk or to halt you just have to close your knees.“

"Do not pull at, but ride the reins.“

"Pulling always causes a disturbance in the horse’s way of going.“

"No pressure, no force and no stress“.

-- Text and Photos © Silke Rottermann for Eurodressage

Related Links
Christine Stückelberger: From Equestrian Super Star to Ambassador of Classical Dressage
Granat, From Ugly Duck to Beautiful Swan
Georg Wahl Again Clinicing at De Steppe
Georg Wahl Passed Away
George Wahl's end of the year 1999 Clinic